A federal grand jury indicted the owner of a footwear importer on charges of evading roughly $5.6 million in customs duties. The indictment alleged that over a period of years employees and others created false invoices understating the value of boots and slippers imported from China.
His counsel’s response is the part worth studying. The importer had been cooperating with CBP for several years. He had deposited more than $4 million with the agency while the matter remained unresolved. And the underlying dispute, counsel said, was a technical question about whether the goods were completed products or component parts, which carry different duty rates.
Cooperation, a multi-million dollar deposit, and a genuine classification argument. Indicted anyway. That combination is why this case is worth understanding rather than skimming.
Valuation Is Where Most Duty Exposure Lives
Classification gets the attention because it is visible and arguable. Valuation is where the money usually is.
Duty is generally assessed on transaction value, meaning the price actually paid or payable for the goods when sold for export to the United States, plus a defined set of statutory additions. Those additions are where importers most often go wrong without intending to:
- Packing costs incurred by the buyer.
- Selling commissions paid by the buyer.
- Assists — materials, components, tooling, dies, moulds, and engineering or design work supplied to the producer free of charge or at reduced cost.
- Royalties or licence fees the buyer must pay as a condition of sale.
- Proceeds of any subsequent resale that accrue to the seller.
An importer who supplies moulds to a Chinese factory, or pays a licence fee on a brand, and declares only the invoice price has understated value. Not dishonestly, necessarily. Just incorrectly, on every entry, for as long as the arrangement runs. Our page on customs valuation and appraisement covers how value is determined.
The Line Between a Dispute and a Fraud
This is the whole of a case like this, and it is worth being precise about where the line sits.
Reading the tariff differently is not the same as inventing a document
Whether footwear enters as a completed product or as component parts is a real question with real consequences, and reasonable people reach different answers. An importer who takes a defensible position, declares consistently with it, and turns out to be wrong has a civil dispute about duties owed. An importer alleged to have created invoices showing prices that were never paid is somewhere else entirely, because a false document is evidence of intent in a way that a wrong tariff code never is.
That distinction drives the civil exposure too. Penalties under 19 U.S.C. § 1592 run on culpability, and the tiers are far apart:
| Culpability | Maximum penalty |
|---|---|
| Fraud | Domestic value of the merchandise |
| Gross negligence | Lesser of domestic value or four times the duty loss |
| Negligence | Lesser of domestic value or two times the duty loss |
On an alleged duty loss in the millions, the difference between the negligence tier and the fraud tier is the difference between a survivable settlement and the end of a business. Which is why the evidence of how declarations were prepared matters more than the tariff question underneath them.
Depositing Duties While a Dispute Is Open
The $4 million deposit is a practice worth knowing about, and it is underused.
Where an importer identifies a potential shortfall and the correct figure is still being worked out, tendering the estimated duties to CBP does several things at once. It stops the revenue loss growing. It demonstrates that the importer is not sitting on money it may owe. And it is a concrete fact to put in front of a deciding officer later, which is worth considerably more than an assurance of good intentions.
It is not a magic shield, as this case demonstrates. It is a reasonable step that improves the civil position and does not resolve the question of how the underlying declarations came to be made.
Prior Disclosure Limits Penalties, Not Prosecution
This is the misunderstanding that matters most, and this case is the clearest illustration of it available.
A valid prior disclosure made before CBP commences a formal investigation dramatically reduces civil penalty exposure. For a negligent violation it can bring the penalty down to interest on the unpaid duties. It is the single most valuable option available to an importer who discovers a problem in its own entries, and it should be on the table the moment a shortfall is suspected.
It is a civil provision
The prior disclosure framework limits what CBP can assess as a civil penalty. It does not confer immunity from criminal prosecution, and a decision by a U.S. Attorney is not constrained by it. An importer who discloses, cooperates for years and deposits millions can still be indicted — and the disclosure itself is a detailed written account of the conduct, sitting in government hands. Where the facts include anything that could be characterised as intentional, the disclosure needs to be prepared with criminal counsel involved from the outset, not treated as a compliance formality.
That is not an argument against disclosing. Doing nothing is worse in almost every case, and the civil upside is enormous. It is an argument for understanding what the document is before writing it.
How Far Back This Reaches
The conduct alleged here spanned nearly two decades. Importers assume old entries are closed. They frequently are not.
Limitations periods in this area can run from the discovery of the violation rather than from the entry, which means a practice running quietly for years does not become safe merely by continuing. Where the same arrangement has been applied to every entry since an assist or a royalty was first overlooked, the exposure accumulates rather than expiring.
The practical implication for any importer reviewing its own entries is that finding a problem in a recent shipment is a reason to look backwards, not a reason to fix it going forward and hope.
Settling It Before It Becomes a Problem
The dispute at the centre of this case was whether goods were completed products or component parts. That is exactly the kind of question CBP will answer in advance.
A binding ruling request puts the question to CBP before the goods move and produces an answer the importer can rely on. It costs a fraction of a dispute and it converts a recurring risk into a settled position. An importer who has a ruling and follows it is in a fundamentally different place from one who took a view and declared on it for seventeen years.
Where a notice has already issued, the response is a petition for mitigation or remission filed within the deadline on it, and the compliance record is what it is built on. Our import compliance page covers the wider set of obligations. Outcomes depend heavily on the specific facts, the compliance history and the documentation available.
Valuation Problem in Your Entries?
The options narrow once CBP opens an investigation. If you suspect a shortfall, the time to get advice is before anyone asks. Contact us for a confidential case evaluation.
Frequently Asked Questions
What has to be included in the value I declare?
Generally the price actually paid or payable for the goods, plus statutory additions including packing costs, selling commissions, assists such as tooling or design work supplied to the producer, royalties or licence fees paid as a condition of sale, and proceeds of resale accruing to the seller.
Can a genuine classification disagreement become a criminal case?
A defensible position declared consistently is a civil dispute about duties owed. What changes the character of a matter is evidence about how the declarations were produced, and documents showing prices that were never paid are evidence of intent in a way a wrong tariff code is not.
Does a prior disclosure protect me from prosecution?
No. It limits civil penalty exposure under § 1592, substantially so, and it does not bind a prosecutor. Where the facts could be characterised as intentional, a disclosure should be prepared with criminal counsel involved rather than treated as a compliance filing.
I found an error in a recent entry. Should I look at older ones?
Yes. Where the same arrangement has applied to every entry, the exposure accumulates rather than expiring, and limitations periods in this area can run from discovery rather than from the entry date. Fixing it going forward does not close what came before.
Legal Disclaimer: This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading it, or contacting Great Lakes Customs Law through this website, does not create an attorney-client relationship. Great Lakes Customs Law does not represent defendants in federal criminal proceedings; references to criminal exposure are general background and anyone facing charges should retain criminal defence counsel. Valuation rules, statutory additions and limitations periods are detailed and fact-specific and should be confirmed against the current provisions for your circumstances. The matter described is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting of an indictment; an indictment is an allegation and the person charged is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty. Laws, regulations and CBP procedures change, and the outcome of any customs penalty matter depends heavily on its specific facts and circumstances. No result is guaranteed or implied. You should consult a licensed attorney about your particular situation before taking or refraining from any action.