Cash Seizures in Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands: When the $10,000 Report Is Actually Required

10–16 minutes

CBP reported seizing approximately $10.6 million in unreported currency across Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands in fiscal year 2014. The figure gets quoted whenever Caribbean cash enforcement comes up. It is also, by itself, close to useless to anyone whose money has actually been taken.

The question that matters in a Caribbean currency seizure is not how much CBP takes in a year. It is whether the reporting requirement applied to that trip at all. And in the Caribbean, more than anywhere else in the United States, the answer is not obvious, because Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands sit on opposite sides of one line and the same side of another.

Two Different Definitions of “the United States”

Federal law uses the phrase “the United States” to mean different things in different statutes, and two of those definitions collide in the Caribbean.

For tariff and entry purposes, the governing concept is the customs territory of the United States. General Note 2 to the Harmonized Tariff Schedule defines it as the States, the District of Columbia, and Puerto Rico. That is the entire list. The U.S. Virgin Islands, Guam, American Samoa, and the Northern Mariana Islands are insular possessions outside the customs territory.

For currency reporting purposes, the governing definition is in the Bank Secrecy Act regulations. 31 C.F.R. § 1010.100(hhh) defines “United States” as “the States of the United States, the District of Columbia, the Indian lands (as that term is defined in the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act), and the Territories and Insular Possessions of the United States.”

The insular possessions are outside one definition and inside the other

The U.S. Virgin Islands is outside the customs territory, which is why CBP inspects travelers arriving from St. Thomas or St. Croix. It is inside the Bank Secrecy Act’s “United States,” which is the definition that controls whether a currency report was required.

Why That Matters

The reporting requirement comes from 31 U.S.C. § 5316. It applies when a person knowingly transports more than $10,000 in monetary instruments at one time from a place in the United States to or through a place outside the United States, or to a place in the United States from or through a place outside the United States.

Read that against the definition. The requirement is triggered by crossing the boundary of “the United States” as the Bank Secrecy Act defines it. Movement between two places that are both inside that boundary does not trigger it, no matter how many customs inspections happen along the way.

Trip Customs inspection? FinCEN 105 required?
Miami to San Juan No. Puerto Rico is in the customs territory. No
St. Thomas to Miami Yes. The USVI is outside the customs territory. No, on the territorial definition
San Juan to St. Thomas Yes, arriving in the USVI No, on the territorial definition
St. Thomas to Tortola, BVI (ferry) Yes Yes. The BVI is a British territory.
San Juan to Santo Domingo Yes Yes. The Dominican Republic is a foreign country.
Nassau or Aruba to the U.S. Yes, at CBP preclearance before departure Yes

The second and third rows are where cases get made and where cases get defended. A traveler flying from St. Thomas to the mainland walks through a CBP inspection. The inspection is real and the customs declaration is real, because merchandise brought from an insular possession has to be declared and a higher personal exemption applies under 19 C.F.R. § 148.33. A traveler who sees a CBP officer, a declaration form, and a baggage search reasonably concludes that this is an international arrival, and so, sometimes, does everyone else in the room.

But the customs declaration and the currency report are two different obligations under two different statutes with two different definitions of where the United States ends. Failing to declare merchandise is a 19 U.S.C. § 1497 problem. Failing to report currency is a 31 U.S.C. § 5316 problem. They are not the same question and they do not have the same answer on a trip between the USVI and the mainland.

What this is and is not

This is an argument, and in the right case a strong one, not a guarantee. CBP officers at USVI and Puerto Rico ports do inspect travelers and do ask about currency, and a seizure can happen regardless. The point is that if a seizure is premised on failure to file a report, the threshold question is whether a report was required on that itinerary, and on a purely domestic-to-insular-possession trip there is a serious argument that it was not. That question gets raised in the response to the seizure, not at the counter.

The Other Two Statutes Are Not Limited the Same Way

A reporting argument does not dispose of every Caribbean currency case, because the government has other theories and they do not all depend on an international crossing.

  • Bulk cash smuggling, 31 U.S.C. § 5332. This requires concealment with intent to evade a reporting requirement, and transport across a U.S. border. Where no report was required, the intent element is difficult. Our page on bulk cash smuggling covers how CBP builds those cases.
  • Structuring, 31 U.S.C. § 5324. Breaking up transport or deposits to avoid a reporting threshold. Again tied to a reporting requirement. See structuring under 31 U.S.C. § 5324.
  • Drug proceeds and money laundering forfeiture. Entirely independent of currency reporting. If the government alleges the money is traceable to an offense, the reporting analysis above is beside the point and the case is about the source of the funds.

Which theory CBP is actually proceeding on appears in the seizure paperwork, and it determines everything about how the case should be handled. The custody receipt and the notice of seizure name the statute. Reading them carefully is the first substantive step in any case.

What the $10.6 Million Figure Is Worth

Worth a brief note, since the number is what put this page on the internet in the first place.

The same CBP release that reported approximately $10.6 million in unreported currency seized across Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands in fiscal year 2014 also stated that “$8.4 million of currency interdictions were reported.” The release did not reconcile the two figures, and they may well measure different things, seizures against interdictions, or one jurisdiction against both.

The practical lesson is not that CBP cannot count. It is that aggregate enforcement statistics are published for communications purposes and are not audited financial data. They are useful for direction of travel and nothing finer. If an annual figure is being cited at you as though it establishes something about your case, it does not.

What the numbers do support is unremarkable and still true: Caribbean ports are active for currency enforcement, San Juan and the USVI airports and seaports among them, and the volume has not gone down in the years since. Our page on cash seized at the San Juan port of entry covers that port specifically.

If CBP Seized Cash From You in Puerto Rico or the USVI

The process is the same one that applies anywhere else in the country, and the deadlines are short.

  • Do not call the port to explain. Post-seizure statements become evidence. Our page on why claimants should stay off the phone with CBP after a seizure explains why this is the single most common unforced error.
  • Read the custody receipt and wait for the notice of seizure. The notice identifies the statute, the amount, and the options. Our guide to responding to the custody receipt covers the first stage.
  • Choose a path deliberately. The election of proceedings form asks you to pick between an administrative petition, an offer in compromise, a court claim, and doing nothing. These are not interchangeable, and the choice is difficult to undo.
  • Preserve the itinerary. In a Caribbean case specifically, boarding passes, ticket records, and the routing of every leg are not background detail. They establish where the trip began and ended, which is the question the reporting analysis turns on.

The full process, including petitions, CAFRA claims, and timelines, is set out in our customs money seizure guide and in how to get seized cash back from CBP.

Cash Seized in Puerto Rico or the U.S. Virgin Islands?

We handle customs currency seizures at ports nationwide, including San Juan, St. Thomas, and St. Croix. If the seizure was premised on a failure to file a currency report, the first question is whether a report was required on your itinerary. Contact us for a confidential case evaluation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to report more than $10,000 when flying from Puerto Rico to the mainland?

No. Puerto Rico is inside the customs territory of the United States and inside the Bank Secrecy Act’s definition of “United States” at 31 C.F.R. § 1010.100(hhh). A flight between Puerto Rico and the mainland is a domestic flight for both customs and currency reporting purposes, and there is no customs inspection and no FinCEN Form 105 requirement.

What about flying from the U.S. Virgin Islands to the mainland?

There is a customs inspection, because the USVI is outside the customs territory of the United States and merchandise has to be declared. But the USVI is an insular possession and therefore inside the Bank Secrecy Act’s definition of “United States,” so the currency reporting requirement under 31 U.S.C. § 5316, which applies to transport to or from a place outside the United States, is not triggered by that itinerary. If cash was seized on that route for failure to file a report, whether a report was required is a threshold issue worth raising.

Why does CBP inspect me coming from St. Thomas if it is U.S. territory?

Because “U.S. territory” and “U.S. customs territory” are different things. General Note 2 to the Harmonized Tariff Schedule limits the customs territory to the States, the District of Columbia, and Puerto Rico. The Virgin Islands, Guam, American Samoa, and the Northern Mariana Islands are insular possessions outside it, so goods brought from them are subject to customs declaration and entry requirements, with a higher personal exemption under 19 C.F.R. § 148.33.

Does the reporting requirement apply to the ferry between the USVI and the British Virgin Islands?

Yes. The British Virgin Islands is a British overseas territory and a place outside the United States. Carrying more than $10,000 in monetary instruments in either direction on that route requires a FinCEN Form 105. The same applies to travel between Puerto Rico and the Dominican Republic or any other foreign country.

Does it matter that the money was not mine?

Not for whether a report was required. Section 5316 applies to the person transporting the monetary instruments, and the obligation attaches to the transport, not to ownership. Ownership matters at a different stage, in establishing who has standing to claim the money and whether an innocent owner defense is available.

Are CBP’s annual seizure statistics reliable?

They indicate scale and trend, not precise accounting. The fiscal year 2014 Caribbean release cited both approximately $10.6 million in currency seized and $8.4 million in currency interdictions without reconciling them. Aggregate enforcement figures are communications material and should not be treated as establishing anything about an individual case.


Legal Disclaimer: This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading it, or contacting Great Lakes Customs Law through this website, does not create an attorney-client relationship. The territorial analysis described here is a general summary of statutory and regulatory definitions and is not a prediction that any particular seizure will be resolved on that basis. CBP may proceed on theories that do not depend on a currency reporting requirement, and the outcome of any seizure or forfeiture matter depends entirely on its specific facts. The enforcement statistics discussed relate to fiscal year 2014 and are historical. Laws, regulations, and CBP procedures change. You should consult a licensed attorney about your particular situation before taking or refraining from any action.

Free Case Review


Get in Touch

Detroit Office

(734) 855-4999

Chicago Office

(773) 920-1840